Int 0658-2011
Waiver of public employee organizations’ rights when submitting grievances to arbitration under the NYC collective bargaining law.
IntroductionEnactedCommittee on Civil Service and Laborintroduced 2011-08-17Local Law 2012/039
Enacted as Local Law 2012/039.
Official record · Legistar
Agenda: 2011-08-17Passed: 2012-06-28Enacted: 2012-06-28
Committee on Civil Service and Labor — Municipal Officers and Employees, Office of Labor Relations, Office of Collective Bargaining, Office of Labor Services, and Municipal Pension and Retirement Systems.
How it compares
24% of similar bills passed
12 passed · 38 died
This bill: 243 days in committee
Similar bills: median 464 days · 93 days when passed
Compared against 50 Introduction bills in Committee on Civil Service and Labor.
Ranked by how closely each matches this bill's topic — closest first:
Int 0292-2004
Collective bargaining rights of certain city employees.
384dFiled
Int 0380-2004
Collective bargaining rights of certain city employees.
294dEnacted
Int 0235-1998-A
Collective Bargaining Law
113dEnacted
Int 0655-2007
Collective bargaining rights of department of environmental protection police officers.
764dFiled
Int 0424-2010
Collective bargaining rights of department of environmental protection police officers.
1140dFiled
Int 0569-1999
Unions Public Employees, Reporting
915dFiled
+ 44 more comparable bills
Sponsors (14)
Lifecycle
IntroducedIntroduced by Council
2011-08-17 · City Council
ActionReferred to Comm by Council
2011-08-17 · City Council
HeardHearing Held by Committee
2012-02-28 · Committee on Civil Service and Labor
ActionAmendment Proposed by Comm
2012-02-28 · Committee on Civil Service and Labor
HeldLaid Over by Committee
2012-02-28 · Committee on Civil Service and Labor
HeardHearing Held by Committee
2012-04-17 · Committee on Civil Service and Labor
ActionAmendment Proposed by Comm
2012-04-17 · Committee on Civil Service and Labor
ActionAmended by Committee
2012-04-17 · Committee on Civil Service and Labor
AdvancedApproved by Committee
2012-04-17 · Committee on Civil Service and Labor
HeldLaid Over by Council
2012-04-18 · City Council
AdvancedApproved by Council
2012-04-30 · City Council
ActionSent to Mayor by Council
2012-04-30 · City Council
ClosedVetoed by Mayor
2012-05-30 · Mayor
HeardHearing Held by Committee
2012-06-27 · Committee on Civil Service and Labor
AdvancedApproved by Committee
2012-06-27 · Committee on Civil Service and Labor
ActionOverridden by Council
2012-06-28 · City Council
Votes (65)
Aye (62)
James Sanders, Jr.James F. GennaroMelissa Mark-ViveritoDomenic M. Recchia, Jr.Larry B. SeabrookJames Sanders, Jr.James F. GennaroMelissa Mark-ViveritoMichael C. NelsonDomenic M. Recchia, Jr.Eric A. UlrichJames VaccaChristine C. QuinnMaria Del Carmen ArroyoCharles BarronGale A. BrewerMargaret S. ChinLeroy G. Comrie, Jr.Elizabeth S. CrowleyInez E. DickensErik Martin DilanDaniel Dromm Mathieu EugeneJulissa Ferreras-CopelandLewis A. FidlerHelen D. FosterFernando Cabrera Daniel R. GarodnickJames F. GennaroVincent J. GentileSara M. GonzalezDavid G. GreenfieldVincent IgnizioLetitia JamesPeter A. KooG. Oliver KoppellKaren KoslowitzBrad S. LanderJessica S. LappinStephen T. LevinMelissa Mark-ViveritoDarlene MealyRosie MendezMichael C. NelsonJames S. OddoAnnabel PalmaDomenic M. Recchia, Jr.Diana ReynaJoel RiveraYdanis A. RodriguezDeborah L. RoseJames Sanders, Jr.Larry B. SeabrookEric A. UlrichPeter F. Vallone, Jr.James G. Van BramerAlbert VannMark S. WeprinDaniel J. Halloran IIIRobert JacksonJumaane D. WilliamsRuben Wills
Absent (3)
Michael C. NelsonEric A. UlrichLarry B. Seabrook
Heard at (8)
City Council · 2012-06-28 · 8:00 PM · Council Chambers - City Hall
Committee on Civil Service and Labor · 2012-06-27 · 1:00 PM · 250 Broadway - Committee Rm, 16th Fl.
Committee on Civil Service and Labor · 2012-06-25 · 1:00 PM · 250 Broadway - Hearing Rm, 16th Fl.
City Council · 2012-04-30 · 1:30 PM · Council Chambers - City Hall
City Council · 2012-04-18 · 1:30 PM · Council Chambers - City Hall
Committee on Civil Service and Labor · 2012-04-17 · 1:00 PM · 250 Broadway - Committee Rm, 14th Fl.
Committee on Civil Service and Labor · 2012-02-28 · 10:00 AM · 250 Broadway - Committee Rm, 16th Fl.
City Council · 2011-08-17 · 1:30 PM · Emigrant Savings Bank - 49-51 Chambers Street
Attachments (16)
- Int. No. 658 - 8/17/11
- Proposed Int. No. 658-A - 2/28/12
- Committee Report 2/28/12
- Hearing Testimony 2/28/12
- Hearing Transcript 2/28/12
- Committee Report 4/17/12
- Hearing Transcript 4/17/12
- Hearing Transcript - Stated Meeting 4-18-12
- Hearing Transcript - Stated Meeting 4/30/12
- Fiscal Impact Statement
- Mayor's Veto Message
- Committee Report 6/27/12
- Hearing Transcript 6/27/12
- Fiscal Impact Statement
- Hearing Transcript - Stated Meeting 6-28-12
- Local Law 39
Full text
Be it enacted by the Council as follows:
Section 1. Declaration of legislative findings and intent. The Council hereby finds that recent litigation has resulted in a judicial decision which holds that, when a public employee organization files a waiver to submit a grievance to arbitration pursuant to a collective bargaining agreement which the organization has with a public employer, the public employee organization waives its right to bring other administrative or judicial actions to address alleged violations of other statutes or rights not contained in the collective bargaining agreement. The Council finds that such a result is contrary to the New York City Office of Collective Bargaining’s longstanding interpretation of the local law. The Council further finds that such a result unfairly prejudices the City’s public employee organizations and the members they represent and that no similar waiver requirement exists in the New York State Taylor Law. Legislation is therefore necessary to rectify this disparity, in order to clarify that a public employee organization waives only its right to submit an alleged contractual dispute under the collective bargaining agreement and no other right when it submits a grievance to arbitration at the New York City Office of Collective Bargaining.
§ 2. Subdivision d of section 12-312 of the administrative code of the city of New York is amended to read as follows:
d. As a condition to the right of a municipal employee organization to invoke impartial arbitration under such provisions, the grievant or grievants and such organization shall be required to file with the director a written waiver of the right, if any, of said grievant or grievants and said organization to submit the [underlying dispute] contractual dispute being alleged under a collective bargaining agreement to any other administrative or judicial tribunal except for the purpose of enforcing the arbitrator’s award. This subdivision shall not be construed to limit the rights of any public employee or public employee organization to submit any statutory or other claims to the appropriate administrative or judicial tribunal.
§ 3. This local law shall take effect immediately.
LS 2659
MWC
4/10/12 7:04PM