Res 0976-2016

By Council Members Dromm, Palma, Rodriguez, Gentile and Chin Whereas, Undocumented immigrants often seek legal services for a myriad of reasons, including assistance with their immigration status; and Whereas, Legal assistance in immigration law should only be provided by a licensed attorney admitted to practice law or a Board of Immigration Appeals ("BIA") accredited representative; and Whereas, Fraudulent service providers routinely take advantage of immigrants seeking such assistance by portraying themselves to be authorized providers of immigration legal services and often charging steep fees, even though they do not possess the appropriate credentials; and Whereas, In 2012, New Immigrant Community Empowerment and the Urban Justice Center conducted a survey of immigrant service providers ("ISPs") in New York City and found that 23% of ISPs surveyed advertised that they provide legal advice; and Whereas, Furthermore, they found that of the ISPs surveyed, not a single ISP had a clear sign posted disclosing that they were not an attorney or BIA accredited representative; and Whereas, The survey results showed that 51.7% of individuals seeking immigration-related legal services felt that they did not receive the help they needed from the ISP they visited; and Whereas, In 2014, the New York State Legislature passed and the Governor signed A.8974-B/ S.6732-A, which added civil and criminal penalties for perpetrators of immigrant service provider fraud; and Whereas, The New York City Council passed Local Law 31 in 2004, which prohibits service providers from representing themselves in a way that could lead a prospective customer to believe that they possess a law license or BIA accreditation; and Whereas, In April of 2015, New York City Council Member Daniel Dromm introduced Int. 746, to amend the administrative code of the City of New York, in relation to preventing the unauthorized practice of immigration law, and will continue to address this issue; and Whereas, In addition to legislation at the city and state levels, there is need for stronger federal legislation to protect immigrants from unauthorized service providers and punish those service providers perpetrating fraudulent schemes; and Whereas, On February 26, 2015, United States ("U.S.") Representative Bill Foster introduced H.R. 1123 or the "Protecting Immigrants from Legal Exploitation Act of 2015," which creates penalties for the unauthorized practice of immigration law and immigration practitioner fraud; and Whereas, H.R. 1123 is co-sponsored by U.S. Representatives Charles Rangel of the 13th district and U.S. Representative Grace Meng of the 6th district, both of whom represent New York; and Whereas, H.R. 1123 would amend the federal code to subject a person who conducts a scheme in connection with any federal immigration law, such as unlawfully providing legal services through fraudulent pretenses to a person in exchange for money or something of value, to fines, imprisonment, or both; and Whereas, H.R. 1123 would amend the federal code to subject a person who falsely represents that such person is an attorney or a BIA accredited representative and provides legal services in any federal immigration law matter, regardless of whether they charged for services, to fines, imprisonment, or both; and Whereas, H.R. 1123 would allow an individual to withdraw an immigration application if that individual can provide evidence that the application was prepared or submitted by a service provider engaged in the unauthorized practice of immigration law, as long as the individual had no prior knowledge of such fraud; and Whereas, H.R. 1123 would amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to waive the restriction on immigrants re-entering the U.S. after departing based on the erroneous advice of an individual engaged in the unauthorized practice of law or immigration practitioner fraud; and Whereas, H.R. 1123 would direct the Secretary of Homeland Security and the Attorney General to conduct public education campaigns for immigrant communities about who is authorized to provide legal services and representation on immigration matters; and Whereas, H.R. 1123 would also direct the Secretary of Homeland Security and the Attorney General to establish programs to award grants to nonprofit organizations that provide direct legal services for immigrants facing removal proceedings or filing affirmative applications and petitions; and Whereas, Immigration services fraud is a national problem that hinders individuals who may be eligible to legally work or reside in the United States from obtaining the legitimate legal services they need; now, therefore, be it Resolved, That the Council of the City of New York calls on the U.S. Congress to pass and the President to sign H.R. 1123, also known as the "Protecting Immigrants from Legal Exploitation Act of 2015," which establishes criminal penalties for the unauthorized practice of immigration law and immigration practitioner fraud. LS# 5793 1/26/2015 MA/WJH/ IP